Subject: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jun 29, 2016 7:40 am
Title in the name. After we took out some guilds I thought "Hey why not ask people what guilds they want." Some guilds will of course stay but I I won't say cause I want to hear all the guilds you guys want to stay. Could you also place them in order of what you think should stay? Tottally up to you though! You can also switch it around and say what guilds you don't want! So get posting guys!
Matt Locket
Posts : 28
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jun 29, 2016 8:03 am
White tiger needs to stay. That is my opinion.
Lyra Vollan
Posts : 234 Location : Isshi Village
Character sheet Name: Astraea Alucard Alignment: Chaotic Evil Mana: (0/0)
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jun 29, 2016 8:34 am
Fairy Tail Grimoire Heart Phantom Lord Lamia Scale Blue Pegasus
Two dark guilds and three light/neutral guillds? Or maybe two of each kind for balance? We don't want everyone swarming one dark guild or one neutral guild.. Or we could even use a non canon guild as well (such as White/Black tiger). Of course I could be wrong, so this is just a thought.
Videns
Posts : 51
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jun 29, 2016 8:47 am
Okay I should have said this. I need solid reasons, like Lyra's. Matt/Eve please, details. And is that the only one you want? More details please!
Matt Locket
Posts : 28
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jun 29, 2016 8:50 am
Hmm… white tiger as it is a neutral guild and it gives more variety, and can make it more interesting. With the other guilds, I am with Lyra and her reasoning
Videns
Posts : 51
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jun 29, 2016 9:08 am
Okay thank you. As of right now black and white tiger aren't going to be regular guild people can join. They shall he saved for later. We could introduce another neutral guild however fir it's replacement. Sound good?
LeeAnn
Posts : 239
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jun 29, 2016 9:12 am
Lyra Vollan wrote:
Fairy Tail Grimoire Heart Phantom Lord Lamia Scale Blue Pegasus
Two dark guilds and three light/neutral guillds? Or maybe two of each kind for balance? We don't want everyone swarming one dark guild or one neutral guild.. Or we could even use a non canon guild as well (such as White/Black tiger). Of course I could be wrong, so this is just a thought.
We could just add a neutral guild for now to even the balence. But we'll see what will happen when the site offically ccomes out again
Videns
Posts : 51
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jun 29, 2016 9:26 am
Sabertooth *Cough cough*
Erzlia Packs
Posts : 50
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jun 29, 2016 2:48 pm
fairytail without them erzila will remain sealed away
Akihiko Mori
Posts : 6
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Thu Jul 07, 2016 11:31 pm
Fairy Tail - Good Grimoire Heart - Evil Phantom Lord - Evil Lamia Scale - Good Blue Pegasus - Neutral Good Sabertooth - Neutral.
I think that about makes it even imo. They are all popular guilds and it would be nice to see them have at least 5 members/character each before we open others. But this is from a Site feedback perspective.
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Fri Jul 08, 2016 5:23 pm
Akihiko Mori wrote:
Fairy Tail - Good Grimoire Heart - Evil Phantom Lord - Evil Lamia Scale - Good Blue Pegasus - Neutral Good Sabertooth - Neutral.
I think that about makes it even imo. They are all popular guilds and it would be nice to see them have at least 5 members/character each before we open others. But this is from a Site feedback perspective.
I agree with the above.
Lyra Vollan
Posts : 234 Location : Isshi Village
Character sheet Name: Astraea Alucard Alignment: Chaotic Evil Mana: (0/0)
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Sun Jul 10, 2016 8:24 pm
L-Sha wrote:
Akihiko Mori wrote:
Fairy Tail - Good Grimoire Heart - Evil Phantom Lord - Evil Lamia Scale - Good Blue Pegasus - Neutral Sabertooth - Neutral
I think that about makes it even imo. They are all popular guilds and it would be nice to see them have at least 5 members/character each before we open others. But this is from a Site feedback perspective.
I agree with the above.
I like this.
LeeAnn
Posts : 239
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Wed Jul 13, 2016 9:08 pm
Agreed.
We will have three legal guilds, one neutral guild nad two dark guilds. Original plan has been set
Pika-Rin
Posts : 4
Subject: Re: What Guilds do you want to stay? Sat Aug 06, 2016 1:15 pm
Hi, I know that this discussion is pretty much long over and done with but, if I may, I would like to give my opinion on the matter as well. I feel that maybe instead of 3 light, 1 neutral and 2 dark guilds. It might be best to keep the numbers even. So have 2 guilds per faction. Reason being, if there's two of each kind, I feel each guild can have a fair shot at getting members. If there's an odd number of guilds between the three factions, it would cause for certain guilds to be overflowing while others are just sitting there with little to no active members. As many of you are fully aware, when it comes to a fairy tail RP setting, many people's character's tend to switch sides or leave their guild for another or become guileless, all for character development and or personal reasons. Therefore, having two guilds per faction, would help even that out to a certain degree. Also, for wanderers, I feel their should be a temporary cap on it as to how many people can become a wanderer until the guilds with less members fill up a bit more and once the guilds with less people get more members and active, we lift the cap.
These are all just ideas that came to me after reading through this topic. Like I said before, I know this discussion is long done, but I felt that my suggestion, might be helpful.
» Hello peeps Mon Aug 01, 2016 10:54 pm by Lyra Vollan
Members106
Most Online360
Newest Member
https://fairytailreborn.forumotion.com/u111
Top posting users this month
No user
Season and Year
Year: X790 Season: Summer Month: July
Credits
Fairy Tail belongs to Hiro Mashima who has all rights to the characters of the manga.
Owner of Fairy Tail Reborn belongs to LeeAnn and power by the host site, Forumotion. The template goes to its rightful owner and edits were made by Melody and LeeAnn. Rule and Regulations were created by LeeAnn. All posts, characters, ideas, and creative content goes to their rightful owner. If you have any questions please contact LeeAnn.